Cardinal vs Blue Jay: An Analysis of These Iconic Birds

Backyard bird watchers love looking out for the bright red and bold blue splashes of color Cardinals and Blue Jays bring to their feeders.

But you might also be wondering what sets these birds apart in terms of diet, behavior, and more—which is exactly what we’re covering in this article

Let’s get started, shall we?

Cardinal vs Blue Jay Physical Characteristics

In this section, we will explore the physical characteristics of two popular bird species, the Cardinal and the Blue Jay. We will compare their size, crest, coloration, beak, plumage, and other features to understand the distinctions between them.


Cardinals are small, yet striking birds known for their vivid red coloration. They are found across North and South America and have become a symbol of beauty in the bird world. Male cardinals are typically more vibrant in color, while females exhibit a more muted, brownish-orange hue tinged with red. This sexual dimorphism helps in gender identification among the species.

Cardinal size usually ranges from 8 to 9 inches (20-23 cm) in length, and they possess a short, thick beak ideal for cracking seeds. Their crest is distinct and gives them an elegant appearance, while their long tails add a flowing quality to their movements. On average, cardinals weigh around 43 grams, making them lighter compared to some other bird species.

Blue Jays

Blue Jays, on the other hand, are slightly larger birds than cardinals, measuring about 9 to 12 inches (23-30 cm) in length. They feature a beautifully patterned blue plumage, with a distinctive crest that sets them apart from other birds. This vibrant blue color is not a result of pigmentation, but rather a light scattering phenomenon in their feathers.

Blue Jays have stout, pointed beaks, which they use for various tasks, including foraging and manipulating objects. They weigh between 65 and 110 grams, making them heavier than cardinals on average. This species also showcases sexual dimorphism, but it is more subtle than in cardinals, with both male and female Blue Jays demonstrating similar coloration.

When observing these two outstanding bird species, it becomes evident that their physical characteristics are unique and distinct, yet both Cardinals and Blue Jays captivate bird enthusiasts with their eye-catching hues and remarkable features.

Habitat and Distribution


The Northern Cardinal is a beautiful bird species that can be found in various parts of the United States, specifically in the eastern and central regions, as well as in Southern Canada1. Their habitat consists mainly of woodlands, gardens, shrublands, and wetlands, providing them with an ideal environment for nesting and foraging.

Northern Cardinals are known to build their nests in dense vegetation, often using materials like twigs, leaves, and grasses to construct their homes2. They are adaptable creatures, which allows them to thrive in a variety of landscapes, from urban settings to more natural environments.

Blue Jays

On the other hand, Blue Jays are also a remarkable bird species that share a similar distribution range with Northern Cardinals, being found throughout eastern North America3. They can be observed inhabiting habitats such as forests, parks, and even suburban areas with suitable tree cover.

Blue Jays prefer to nest in trees or dense shrubs, often at considerable heights4. Their nest-building materials consist of twigs, leaves, and roots, with the addition of some mosses and lichen for extra insulation. Similar to Northern Cardinals, Blue Jays display adaptability to different environments, making them a common sight in various settings.

In summary, both Northern Cardinals and Blue Jays can be found across vast regions of eastern and central United States, as well as Southern Canada. Their habitats include woodlands, gardens, shrublands, and wetlands, where they build their nests using locally available materials and can adapt to both natural and urban landscapes.

Feeding Habits

Blue Jays and Cardinals have quite a few similarities when it comes to their diets. Both species are omnivores, which means they enjoy a mix of plant-based and animal-based foods. In this section, we’ll explore the different aspects of their feeding habits.

These birds have a particular fondness for seeds and nuts. Some of the popular choices include sunflower seeds, peanuts, safflower seeds, and cracked corn. They also enjoy grains like millet and nyjer seed. To ensure that your backyard Blue Jays and Cardinals have access to these treats, consider investing in some suitable bird feeders.

While seeds and nuts are an essential part of their diet, Blue Jays and Cardinals also consume insects. This adds valuable protein to their diets, particularly when they’re feeding their young. Insects like caterpillars, beetles, and ants are among their preferred choices. In addition to seeds and nuts, incorporating fruits into their diet is vital. Cardinals and Blue Jays love munching on fruits, such as berries, apples, and cherries.

Regarding the eating technique, Blue Jays and Cardinals are known for their unique approach. These birds favor a “grab-and-go” method, where they often snatch a mouthful of food and fly to another location to consume it, allowing them to keep an eye on their surroundings and protect themselves from potential predators.

In summary, Blue Jays and Cardinals have diverse diets, mainly consisting of seeds, nuts, fruits, and insects. Providing a variety of these food items in your feeder can help attract these beautiful birds to your backyard, allowing you to enjoy their vibrant colors and captivating behaviors up close.

Nesting and Reproduction

When it comes to nesting, both the Blue Jay and the Cardinal have their distinctive approaches. Blue Jays usually build their nests on tree branches or within tree forks, using a mixture of twigs, grasses, and tree bark. The nests are sturdy and bowl-shaped, giving them essential security as they raise their young ones. On the other hand, Cardinals create cup-shaped nests made from twigs, grass, and bark strips. They often prefer shrubs, thickets, or small trees for added protection from predators.

Eggs play a crucial role in the reproduction of both these bird species. Blue Jays typically lay between four to six eggs, which are light green or blue in color with brown spots. The female Blue Jay is responsible for incubating the eggs for about 17-18 days before they hatch. In contrast, Cardinals lay a similar number of eggs—usually three to four—appearing in a pale green or blue color with brown speckles. Cardinal females do the incubation as well, taking around 11-13 days for the eggs to hatch.

The juvenile stage of both bird species exhibits noticeable differences in their appearance. Juvenile Blue Jays have a duller plumage compared to adults, with less vibrant blue hues and less distinct markings. As they mature, their feathers become brighter and more well-defined. In contrast, juvenile Cardinals have a muted coloration, appearing grayish-brown with a touch of red in their crest and wings. As these young cardinals grow, their feathers transform into the vibrant red, which is characteristic of adult males, while females keep a muted red-brown color.

Young Blue Jays and Cardinals are heavily dependent on their families during their early stages of development. Parents from both species feed their young by regurgitating insects, seeds, and berries. They continue this method of feeding until the juveniles can forage independently.

Lastly, both bird species can be territorial during the breeding season. Blue Jays and Cardinals tend to become increasingly aggressive towards other birds that encroach on their nesting areas. It’s not uncommon to see Blue Jays resorting to intimidating displays and harsh calls, while Cardinals engage in chase battles and have a “chip” call to assert their territory.

Overall, despite their distinct nesting and reproductive habits, both Blue Jays and Cardinals share a strong commitment to raising and protecting their offspring, ensuring the survival of their majestic species.

Behavior and Vocalization


Cardinals, known for their vibrant red feathers and stunning appearance, have a calm and laid-back demeanor. They are content to stay within their territories and rarely show aggression. Cardinal vocalizations are characterized by their mellower tones and clear two-parted whistles. This whistling serves as an enchanting soundtrack in their natural habitats, which can help birdwatchers identify them with ease.

Their behavior is gentle even when it comes to defending their territories, as they generally prefer to avoid confrontations. Cardinals’ vocal range can vary greatly, and individuals may develop their own unique melodies, which adds to the charm and appeal of these beautiful birds.

Blue Jays

In contrast to the mellow behavior of cardinals, blue jays exhibit a more assertive and sometimes even aggressive stance when it comes to protecting their territories. Their distinctive blue and white plumage, along with the blue crest on their heads, makes them stand out in their surroundings.

Blue jay vocalizations tend to sound harsher and sharper, making them easily distinguishable from the mellower tones of cardinals. Their calls range from simple calls to a more complex set of sounds known as the “whisper song.” The whisper song is a soft, quiet mixture of clicks, chucks, whirrs, whines, liquid notes, and elements of other calls, which can last longer than two minutes1. This fascinating vocal variety is unlike any other bird species and adds to the allure of blue jays.

In conclusion, both cardinals and blue jays exhibit distinct behaviors and vocalizations that set them apart from each other. By observing these differences, bird enthusiasts can better understand and appreciate the unique attributes and habits of these splendid birds.

Predators and Threats

Cardinals and blue jays are both beautiful and vibrant birds, with unique characteristics and behaviors. However, they also share common predators in their North American habitats. Hawks, such as the marsh hawk and Cooper’s hawk, often prey on these birds. Other bird predators, like long-eared owls and falcons, can also pose a threat to both cardinals and blue jays.

Interestingly, even some larger birds like bald eagles and golden eagles have been known to prey on cardinals. In addition to birds of prey, other animals can be dangerous to these colorful species. Chipmunks, for instance, may attempt to attack and eat cardinals, although this is a less common threat.

One important fact to note is that blue jays, despite their somewhat aggressive behavior towards other birds, can be quite protective of their own kind. They’ve been observed attacking hawks, owls, and even cats that get too close to their territory. This protective nature, however, doesn’t appear to extend to cardinals, as blue jays don’t seem to actively scare them away.

To summarize, both cardinals and blue jays face various threats in the wild, including hawks, owls, falcons, chipmunks, and larger birds like eagles. Blue jays, in particular, show a strong sense of solidarity among their own species, demonstrating aggressive behavior towards potential predators to defend their territory. Overall, the fascinating world of these two colorful birds is not only an example of the beauty of nature but also showcases the realities of survival.

Symbolism and Spiritual Meaning

Cardinals and blue jays are both admired for their beauty and elegance. These birds are often associated with various forms of symbolism and spiritual meaning. The striking shades of blue found in blue jays and the vibrant red hues of cardinals make them stand out in the wild and capture the attention of many bird enthusiasts.

When it comes to their spiritual significance, the blue jay and cardinal can symbolize the balance of opposing energies. Blue jays represent fiery intensity, power, and passion, while cardinals embody peace and harmony. Seeing both a cardinal and blue jay together can signify the perfect balance between these two opposite poles.

In some cultures, spotting a cardinal and blue jay together is considered a sign of good luck. This belief stems from the idea that these two birds are natural enemies. When they are seen in the same location, it is thought to symbolize peace and harmony in the area.

Cardinals are also known to represent the presence of a lost loved one. In many spiritual circles, they are believed to bring messages from the spirit world and act as a reminder that our loved ones continue to watch over us. When a cardinal appears, it can serve as a comforting signal that someone we miss is still close by, watching over us and supporting us.

As for state birds, the cardinal holds the honor of being the state bird for seven U.S. states: Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, North Carolina, Ohio, Virginia, and West Virginia. With its distinct beauty and symbolism, it is no wonder that the cardinal has become such a beloved emblem in these states. In contrast, the blue jay is not the state bird for any U.S. states, although it is a frequent inhabitant of various North American regions.

In conclusion, both cardinals and blue jays hold unique symbolism and spiritual meaning. The striking appearance of these birds, combined with their cultural significance and associations with balance, good luck, lost loved ones, and state pride, make them captivating subjects for discussion and appreciation.

Family and Taxonomy

Cardinals and Blue Jays are two popular and colorful bird species often seen in North America. Despite their eye-catching appearances, they belong to separate families within the avian taxonomy.

The Cardinal, with its bright red plumage and distinctive crest, is a member of the Cardinalidae family. This family consists of various songbirds, most of which are marked by their vibrant colors. On the other hand, the Blue Jay, known for its dominant blue color pattern with a white underside, is part of the Corvidae family. This family includes crows, ravens, and magpies, among other species.

Both the Cardinal and Blue Jay, as part of the Passeriformes order, are classified as passerines or songbirds. Specifically, the scientific name for the Blue Jay is Cyanocitta cristata. Although these birds share similarities such as being passerines, their genera are distinct.

A key difference between these two families is their geographical distribution and migratory patterns. The Blue Jay, native to eastern North America, is found throughout most of the eastern and central United States, with some eastern populations being migratory. Their range extends up to Newfoundland, Canada, where they are residents, as well as across southern Canada where they breed. In contrast, the Cardinal’s habitat spans from the southeastern United States up to southern Ontario, Canada, and they are typically non-migratory.

In summary, while Cardinals and Blue Jays share some similarities as colorful songbirds belonging to the Passeriformes order, their taxonomic classification places them into separate families and genera. Both birds serve as stunning examples of nature’s beauty within their respective Cardinalidae and Corvidae families.

Identification and Birdwatching

When it comes to birdwatching, the ability to identify different species is essential. In this section, we’ll discuss the key identification features of both the Blue Jay and the Cardinal, as well as some interesting facts for birdwatchers to observe.

One of the most striking features of the Blue Jay is its blue crest on their heads. The bird has striking blue and white plumage, which makes it easily recognizable. In contrast, the Cardinal exhibits vibrant red feathers, a distinctive crest, and black facial markings. This vivid coloration makes both birds a delight to watch and identify.

Another aspect of identification involves recognizing the birds’ vigor and behavior. Blue Jays tend to be more aggressive compared to the more peaceful Cardinal. During the juvenile stage, both birds will have less vibrant colors than their adult counterparts. However, as they mature, their colors will become brighter and more pronounced.

In terms of flight speed, Blue Jays are known for their swift and agile movements. Observing their speed can help birdwatchers identify the Blue Jay in the wild. On the other hand, Cardinals are not as fast, but they do exhibit a unique flight pattern: they glide gracefully with intermittent flaps of their wings. Understanding these patterns is essential for birdwatchers.

Finally, it’s worth noting the average lifespan of these remarkable birds. Blue Jays typically have a lifespan of about 7 years in the wild, while Cardinals can live up to 15 years. This difference in longevity can play a role in the populations observed by birdwatchers during their outdoor excursions.

In summary, identifying Blue Jays and Cardinals involves observing their coloration, behavior, juvenile stage, flight speed, and lifespan. These factors contribute to the fascinating world of birdwatching and foster a better understanding of these beautiful creatures.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the differences in size and appearance between blue jays and cardinals?

Blue jays and cardinals have distinct appearances and sizes. Blue jays are typically between 65 and 110 grams with blue and white feathers, forming a crest on their head. Cardinals, on the other hand, weigh around 43 grams on average, and they feature a bright red body with black around their beak and eyes, making them visually larger and more vibrant in color1.

Do blue jays and cardinals share similar habitats?

Both blue jays and cardinals can be found in the eastern and central parts of North America. They tend to live in similar habitats such as forests, wooded areas, backyards, and gardens. While they may share the same environment, these species usually have different nesting habits, with cardinals preferring shrubs and small trees and blue jays opting for higher locations in larger trees2.

What do blue jays and cardinals eat?

Blue jays and cardinals have similar diets, mainly consisting of seeds. Some common foods they both enjoy include sunflower seeds, peanuts, safflower seeds, cracked corn, millet, and nyjer seed3. While they primarily feast on seeds, they also eat insects, fruits, and small invertebrates.

Are there any known hybrid species involving cardinals and blue jays?

To date, there have been no confirmed reports of hybrid species that involve cardinals and blue jays. They belong to different families and genera, making it unlikely for them to produce offspring together4.

What do cardinal and blue jay tattoos symbolize?

Cardinal and blue jay tattoos often represent various symbolic meanings. Cardinal tattoos can symbolize love, faith, loyalty, and vitality, while blue jay tattoos are seen as representing intelligence, resourcefulness, and determination. Each bird’s vibrant color also adds to the visual appeal and symbolism of the tattoo.

Is there any significance to seeing a blue jay and a cardinal together?

According to various folklores, witnessing a cardinal and blue jay together is believed to be a sign of good luck. These two birds are often considered natural enemies, so when spotted in the same location, it symbolizes peace and harmony5. Nevertheless, it is essential to see this belief as a cultural anecdote rather than a scientifically proven fact.


  1. 2 3
  2. 2
  3. 2
  4. 2

Leave a Comment